Where would you put the quotation marks in the following?
A) "Quotation marks", he said.
B) "Quotation marks," he said.
The comma comes before the final quotation mark. So, B is correct.
Also, note the lowercase 'h'. A common mistake is to use a capital:
"Quotation marks," He said.
Use a lowercase letter after your quote mark. It's the same sentence, after
all.
But what about question marks in speech? Where do you put those? Well, it's either this:
A) "Do I need lowercase or uppercase after a question mark?", he asked.
or this:
B) "Do I need lowercase or uppercase after a question mark?", He asked.
Which is correct? The first one, A. The question mark is part of the speech. But it's not the end of the sentence. So it's a lowercase letter after the comma - 'he asked' and not 'He asked'. Some people would complain about the comma, though. Do you really need one before 'he'? I say, yes - it's a subordinate clause.
.
You can go quite far with your punctuation by learning
the basics of the main clause and the subordinate clause.
Main Clause: can stand by itself and
still make sense
Subordinate Clause: can't stand by itself
and still make sense
Take these two as an example:
The boy went to the store
He got lost
The first one is the main clause. It makes sense if you said it to someone.
All right, they may say, "Which boy? Which store? What the hell are
you talking about?" But they'll know that there was a person who went
somewhere.
The second example is a subordinate clause. It wouldn't make sense if you
said it to someone. They would want to know, "Who got lost? Lost where?
What the hell are you talking about?"
You'd sound like a crazy person if you spoke in subordinate clauses.
But, if you joined the two together, the person you're talking to might
not think you're nuts:
The boy went to the store. He got lost.
(Obviously, don't blurt that out to a complete stranger. Wait until the
stranger says, "Did you hear about that boy?" Then you can say,
"The boy went to the store. He got lost.")
You can sound less crazy by making it all one sentence. Just get rid of
the full stop/period and replace it with a comma:
The boy went to the store, he got lost.
So that it doesn't sound like two separate thoughts, you can add a
conjunction before the subordinate clause:
The boy went to the store, but he got
lost.
Now, the person who asked if you heard about that boy will say, "Yeah,
that boy. Listen, I have to go. Real quick." With your knowledge of
adverbs you can say to him, "Don't you mean 'really quickly'?"
A lot of creative writers will turn a subordinate into a sentence. Terry
Pratchet was a master at this. Here's a quote from 'Lords and Ladies' by
way of example:
Elves are wonderful. They provoke wonder.
Elves are marvellous. They cause marvels.
Elves are fantastic. They create fantasies.
Elves are glamorous. They project glamour.
Elves are enchanting. They weave enchantment.
Elves are terrific. They beget terror.
To sum up:
Main Clause - comma - Subordinate Clause
Make sense - comma - Don't make sense
You have to take care with your commas when you
have a list of things, especially in the X, Y and Z format. For example:
Purple, Brown and Blue
Purple, Brown, and Blue
The first one suggests that you want purple and a mix of brown and blue.
The second one suggests you want three separate colours. Here's another
one:
Wine, women, and song
Wine, women and song
The first implies you want three things: the wine, the women, and later
a bit of Karaoke. The second example implies you'd be satisfied with a couple
of drinks at your table while listening to a few female cabaret singers.
The comma before the 'and' is known as the Oxford Comma (or the serial
comma). The Guardian has a good misuse
of the Oxford Comma:
"I dedicate this book to my parents,
Martin Amis and JK Rowling."
Unless the author's parents really are Martin and JK, it should be this:
"I dedicate this book to my parents, Martin Amis, and JK Rowling."
A colon is used to clarify something, or before a list
of things:
To clarify: use a colon.
On this page, we discussed the following:
quotation marks, commas, semicolons, colons.
The colon is going out of fashion. In the first example, you could
use a comma instead:
To clarify, use a colon.
In modern publishing, especially in fiction, you don't see too many colons
and semicolons. They are considered too old-fashioned.
Don't bother with semicolons; they're dead; nobody uses them anymore.
If you do want to use a semicolon then they join two or more clauses together.
The clauses are related. You could use a comma, but that would be too weak.
If that sounds complicated then you know why the semicolon is just about
dead.